Tuesday, March 17, 2009
Module 4 - Musings
Evaluating websites is something I have also been doing but not on a very sophisticated level. This will certainly help me in my studies as I progress through my degree.
Module 4 - Evaluating the Web
Seeing as though Wikipedia is not considered a reliable source for academic research I thought I would evaluate the article I found in my previous task, the article is on the Internet.
Using a tutorial on evaluating websites I will use the evaluation criteria to write an annotated bibliography of this page.
The purpose of the site is to provide information rather than to advocate a point of view or attempt to sell a product or service.
The author of the site is unable to be established. As Wikipedia is an encyclopedia that is able to be edited by anyone, this is where it falls down in its academic credibility. The article in question is well referenced with links to various other topics listed throughout the article. As it fails in the "reliability and validity" stakes as far as academia is concerned, Wikipedia is still a useful tool in beginning research on a chosen topic, even if the site itself cannot be referenced.
Well written articles will provide links to outside sources for further reading and articles or sections of the article that are not well referenced will have a notice advising this is the case. The article chosen for this task is "locked" and has "semi-protection" which means that anonymous users cannot edit it.The content of the article is an overview of the Internet, its history of development, uses and issues such as censorship. The "Social Impact" section of the article is not referenced and is noted as such. This indicates that further editing of this section of the article is required.
The history tab in Wikipedia allows you to see the edits that have been done on this page, the last being on 7th April 2009. This shows that the article in question is current and has been updated in the last week.
Whilst I would not use this article in my academic writing it is a useful overview of the topic of the Internet. There are a variety of references and external sites which I could utilise to extend my search for more "reliable" information resources. As the page is not trying to sell me something or promote a particular point of view then I considered it worthy of consideration in research.
I found this exercise to be very beneficial. It validated some of the ways I currently researched on the internet but also provided some additional hints. When using Google to search I look at the title and URL to see who and what has published it. Academic articles would be up the top of my list in regards to reliability with blogs being towards the bottom. Looking for how many times an article has been cited or a web page linked to is a new skill for me and hopefully one that will provide me with a more efficient way of searching as I can get easily distracted!
Module 4 - Organising search information
Site #1This first site is an article from Wikipedia on the internet.
There is no author or rather many authors as Wikipedia is an encyclopedia that anyone can update.
Wikipedia is a great starting place for research as it contains millions of articles, better than the old Encyclopedia Britannica's from my school days.
Most articles contain citations and links to further information which could be further Wiki articles or external links. These citations aid in taking a the first step in researching a topic and the articles are great for providing background information or an overview of the topic. Some articles will have notes at the top saying that there is not enough citations and could people please fix them up making you aware that the article may not be very accurate.
Site #2The second search result I choose was a link to the CSIRO's Internet Communications page.
This site is authored by CSIRO and contains a wealth of information on ICT technology and developments in the field. As this is an Australian website it also provides context for localised information.
Site #3The last site I have choose is a tutorial on how to effectively use the internet for media and communications research.
It is provided by Intute and will provide assistance in refining my searching capabilities. The guide for the tutorial (perhaps the author, perhaps not) is "Jez Conolly, Subject Librarian, University of Bristol". I'm hoping he can take me on an enlightening journey!
How do I store information. Well my bookmarks for sites that are useful, either generally or for assignment research, are stored with delicious. Del.ic.ious is a "social bookmarking" website where bookmarks are shared amongst users. Bookmarks can be tagged for easy sorting and the software is easily integrated with Mozilla Firefox.
For storing references for assignments I use Endnote which is a bibliographic database tool (and free through the Curtin Library, yeah!). This software is helpful in storing references and organising them by subject. There is also the ability to choose the appropriate citation format as different types are use for different subjects. It is also integrated with Microsoft Word 2007 allowing citations to be added as you write and a bibliography created in the appropriate format when you are done. Even though Word 2007 contains bibliographic referencing features, the citations styles are limited and are not able to be edited.
Module 4 – Boolean search
What is Boolean and how does it relate to the internet? Here is a definition from the Internet Tutorials
website:
"Much database searching is based on the principles of Boolean logic. Boolean logic refers to the logical relationship among search terms, and is named for the British-born Irish mathematician George Boole."
Boolean searching uses the the words OR and AND and NOT in which are know as "operators".
So in using the same search terms (Internet and communication) in the previous task I will use Boolean logic whilst searching Google.
OR
Using the OR operator clearly brings up more results than searching for indivdiual terms. It is "most commonly used to search for synonymous terms or concepts".
Adding another related search term such as "web" more than doubles the amount of results.
AND
Using this Boolean operator allows you to reduce the number of results returned as it looks for specific words.
It is quite surprising how dramatically the use of AND reduces the number of pages indexed in this search!
NOTThis operator is used to exclude words from your search.
Now for some questions. Which Boolean search would result in:
- biggest # of hits - OR
- information most relvant to search - combination of OR and AND and NOT
- info only from uni sources - AND
Module 4 - Searching the Web
Firstly I read up about different types of web searches using a net.TUTOR tutorial which is a simple overview of the vary kinds of tools available to assist in mining data from the web. I was excited to discover Intute, a research site that allows you to filter by area of interest such as Science, Art, Social Sciences or Health. I found an interesting site for Internet for Social Research Methods which I think will be a useful tutorial and may save me some time in the future when preparing for assignments!Ok, so Google would be what is know as a web index. It utilises software which "indexes" pages on a website by trawling through the pages and making an index of all the words listed on it, similar to an index in a book. It is capable of finding a huge amount of info but as you are probably aware, not necessarily what you are after.
The next type of search is using a meta-searcher such as MetaCrawler which will use a variety of search engines to locate what you are after. MetaCrawler searches Google, Yahoo, MSN Search and Ask all at the same time, bonus!
Some smart searching techniques are also listed in the tutorial to help drill down to a more specific result. Such as:
- + or AND e.g. +Internet +communication or Internet AND communication
- ADJ or NEAR for words that are close to each other
- * in Google between words you are searching to pick up any variables
- Refining the search using advanced filters such as restricting the type of domain (.gov, .edu, .org etc.)
- Using the "find similar" link in Google to find pages similar to one that has the info you require
- "related:" followed by a URL of a site you know to find similar sites
Ok for this task i will be doing some different searches using a number of tools to check out what the difference in results might be. for this task my search query in all cases will be +Internet +communication, keeping with the theme of this unit.

Firstly Google, here are the results.
The first web page listed is a Wikipedia article on the topic of the Internet.
The search found 94,500.000 pages related to my search. Way to many to wade through when your assignment is due really soon!

The same search will be performed using Copernic Agent Basic to see what results it yields.
So the first website listed was for Mobile CU - Internet Communications, a site for the ICT industry. Not exactly what I was looking for.
The search found 44 results for my criteria.
I have to say I'm a little disappointed as I assumed this software would find more results but maybe it is just a more "refined" result.
On analysing the pages listed in the later search many of the pages listed have the words "internet" and/or "communication" listed in the page title or summary. Many of the pages are similar to the google search results. Perhaps using the free version has limited the number of engines I can access and prevents a larger scope.
Still unsure which has provided me with the best search results. I think part of the reason is that I am used to sifting through results with Google and at times enjoy the places you end up when looking at results. Maybe I've just been "branded" and find it hard to move away from something that is familiar and common place. I will check out Copernic Agent when completing my assignment to see whether I achieve better results. Maybe my search query was just too broad...


