So for this task I need to have a look at email lists, off to Yahoo to browse some of their groups. How overwhelming! I found myself sitting there thinking "what topic do i want to look at?" So I tried "jump rope" and of course there were not that many active groups. One required me to be attending some primary school somewhere in America which pretty much ruled me out straight away. Good on those kids for setting up their own Yahoo group.Tried a broader category, "Australian Native Plants" with 20 different groups found. Some groups had a few hundred members and some with as little as 5. I'm wondering how effective an online group is without a certain number of members? Is there a minimum number of people needed or is 2 enough to class it as communication? Or is it measured on the number of interactions or their frequency?
Had a look at the "australiannativeplantlovers" group and discovered this interesting post!
It made me consider the fact there may be many Internet users, like myself, who browse the net for answers and solutions to problems, but never ask any questions. Perhaps the netiquette of reading other posts first to try not to ask the same question twice may make someone hesitate in asking, especially on a large list, group, forum, discussion board. Most of the posts on this group were 'hello' type posts and no action since November 2007...boring.
Checked out topica site as listed in the course notes. I understand now what you mean when you say "be aware that many of these groups may not always accurately advertise their content", how true. I checked out an Adventure Travel group, all the posts were by the same person with links sending you off to some religious persons blog?!? The echo in the garden surely made up for this one.
What are the pros and cons of email lists versus discussion boards?
Personally I'm a big fan of the discussion board as it allows people to ask questions (detailed even) and have a large (potential) community available to provide a solution. This discussion also allows for other people outside of the group to also gain knowledge from the topic. From reading this "how stuff works" article the biggest difference between a newsgroup and a discussion board is a newsgroup is replicated on many servers ("decentralized") and a discussion board is hosted on one. For a lively and informative discussion board there needs to be regular activity as you are having a conversation. No one wants to sit in a room staring at the walls with no one talking!
Email lists are great for newsletters from groups, organisations, lists etc that you have signed up for. You can always unsubscribe later if there is too much traffic. Not something I personally go out seeking, and generally end up on one accidentally when signing up for a site account, for whatever reason. With the many other forms of communication (mobiles, email, facebook, im etc) i wonder if the old email list is destined to fade into the past and be replaced with say, twitter?
Are there certain kinds of communication or purposes more suited to one than the other?
As noted above email lists are good for sending irregular information to a number of people (large or small), from a local neighbourhood gardening group newsletter to a check out these new phones from a mobile provider.
Personally i prefer the discussion board/forum much more, where you can post a message and return to your answer at another time to see if it has been answered. It is not forced upon you to read or respond. I have found a lot of information on a variety of topics via forums. They are an interesting space to read a wide range of opinions/solutions to questions or issues and at times provide an interesting timeline as someone attempts to get the information they are seeking. I think discussion boards are good for groups of people interested in a particular topic/genre/area that they can share information about and discuss ideas, such as this course unit or in business by a project team.

No comments:
Post a Comment